Mysteries of the Universe, Explained
©2002 Charity Mason
Dear Walking Encyclopedia,
I've heard of (and seen) some inept people,
but I've never heard of anyone being
referred to as “ept.” Why? While we're
about it, I've also had people tell
me they were “overwhelmed,” but
never “underwhelmed” or even “whelmed.” Why
is that? –M.F.
Dear M.F.:
When it comes to inept people, they're
everywhere, but the reason “ept” people
are rather like those baby pigeons
of lore is because there aren't any.
Yeah, that's right; you can be inept all
you want, but the fact is, the opposite
of “inept” is “apt.” According
to Webster's New World College Dictionary
(Third Edition), the word “inept” comes
from the French word “inepte,” which comes
from the Latin word “ineptus.” “Ineptus” was
derived from the prefix in (meaning “not”)
and the root word aptus, which
means “suitable.” Therefore,
something that is “inept” is, literally, “not
suitable.” As for your question regarding “overwhelmed,” “underwhelmed,” and “whelmed,” well,
the answer is a little trickier. Clearly, “overwhelmed” is
a word, so we'll discard that for the
time being and focus on the other two.
Again, according to WNWCD, “underwhelmed” is,
indeed, a word (even though my spellchecker
went “ptooie” when I typed it). It is
an “ironic allusion to “overwhelmed.” (You
can decide for yourself what that means.)
The definition of “underwhelm” is “to
fail to make a good impression or have
a significant impact on.” A quick flip
of the pages, and it can be ascertained
that “whelmed” is also a word (and one
my spellchecker actually knows—go figure).
It means two things: “to submerge, cover,
or engulf” or “to overpower or crush.” Both “overwhelmed” and “underwhelmed” derive
from “whelmed,” which comes from the Middle
English word welman , which came from
the (surprise!) Old English word
whelman. It means (drumroll, please):
to overwhelm. As for why we never hear “underwhelm” or “whelm,” well,
my guess would be that because “whelm” and “overwhelm” mean
essentially the same thing—and “overwhelm,” with
more syllables, sounds fancier—that “whelm” was
dropped from our everyday vocabulary.
As for underwhelm… well, I would guess
that our society just got so busy and,
well, overwhelmed, that we forgot how
to be underwhelmed, so we stopped saying
it. But feel free to revive it, if
the urge hits you.
Dear Walking Encyclopedia,
Who was the original Murphy of Murphy's Law? –K.L.
Dear K.L.:
Are you an optimist or a pessimist? According to Murphy Laws Site, the eternal pessimist who coined the phrase, “if anything can go wrong, it will,” was none other than “ Capt. Edward A. Murphy, an engineer working on Air Force Project MX981, (a project) designed to see how much sudden deceleration a person can stand in a crash.” According to the story, the law was first “discovered” at Edwards Air Force Base in 1949 in response to a fellow who continually messed things up. But theories on the origin of the phrase disagree. Some say that Murphy's First Law (as it has come to be known) has its origins in prehistory while others credit a magazine writer with the distinction of coining it. However, there seems to be a lot of pessimists in this world, as several more Laws (also attributed to Murphy) have cropped up over the years, including “If there is a possibility of several things going wrong, the one that will cause the most damage will be the one to go wrong.
Corollary: If there is a worse time for something to go wrong, it will happen then.” But you can't forget O'Toole's First Law: “Murphy was an optimist.”